I'm not a selection member nor do I have any input on any boards but I will tell you this. For every sought after profession, field, or award, there are a select group of applicants that will meet every criteria. For those few individuals, they will very rarely have to cross their fingers, and hope, because they know they are already "best qualified". For those of us that made mistakes early on, part of those mistakes are realizing the long term implications of our actions. I was one of the waivered selectees but hard work, and TIMING ended up being on my side when I was selected. The army was taking lots of waivers, and I got lucky. People in front of and behind me weren't as lucky. It worked out for me, but it hasn't always and it might not later in life. Unfortunately that's the nature of life and of the Army. Sometimes it works out, sometimes it doesn't, but if you do everything you can and you still don't make it, then you weren't in the right place at the right time. Sorry if it sounds harsh, but that's just the way it is. Hind sight is 20/20 and stuff does come back to bite you in the ass in ways you didn't expect. Best of luck.